Why Your Personal Brand Matters in Acquisition Deal Flow

TL;DR: Most acquisition entrepreneurs focus 100% on outbound strategies. In today’s newsletter, I dive into how building your personal brand for acquisitions creates higher-quality inbound opportunities with less competition.

A strong brand can increase response rates by 3-5x while attracting sellers who already trust you — even before the first conversation.

This week’s newsletter is from Ross Tomkins:

When I first started my acquisition journey, I made a critical mistake that many entrepreneurs make:

I focused entirely on outbound strategies, constantly reaching out to potential sellers through LinkedIn, direct mail, and broker relationships. While these approaches are valuable, I was missing half of the equation.

The breakthrough came when I realized that acquisition isn't just about finding businesses; it's also about being found by the right sellers. This is where building your acquisition brand becomes crucial.

Your acquisition brand is how you're perceived in the marketplace by business owners, advisors, and other stakeholders.

A strong brand doesn't just supplement your outbound efforts, it creates inbound opportunities that are often higher quality and come with less competition.

Why Personal Branding Matters for Deal Flow

Think of your acquisition strategy as a balance between pushing and pulling. Most acquisition entrepreneurs focus 90-100% of their efforts on outbound activities—LinkedIn outreach, direct mail campaigns, cold calling, and broker relationships. In my experience, the ideal balance is closer to 60% outbound and 40% inbound.

This balanced approach creates a flywheel effect where your outbound efforts enhance your brand, and your brand makes your outbound efforts more effective.

When a business owner receives an acquisition inquiry, their first question is often: "Who is this person?" Their next action is typically to Google you and check your LinkedIn profile. What they find dramatically influences how they perceive your outreach.

Consider these two scenarios:

Scenario 1: Weak Brand Presence A business owner receives your LinkedIn message and searches for you online. They find a basic LinkedIn profile with minimal information, no personal website, no content or media mentions, and no evidence of industry expertise. Their likely conclusion: "This is just another tire-kicker or broker fishing for listings."

Scenario 2: Strong Brand Presence The same business owner finds a comprehensive LinkedIn profile positioning you as an acquisition entrepreneur, a professional website explaining your approach, articles demonstrating your knowledge, and testimonials from previous transactions. Their likely conclusion: "This person seems credible and might be worth talking to."

The difference in response rates between these scenarios can be dramatic. In my experience, a well-developed acquisition brand can increase positive response rates by 3-5x compared to identical outreach without brand support.

Real Results from Brand-Building Efforts

Let me share some concrete results from my own brand-building journey. When I first started reaching out to physiotherapy practice owners with no established acquisition brand, my response rate was approximately 8%.

After six months of deliberate brand building, creating content, speaking at industry events, and developing a professional online presence, my response rate more than tripled to 27% using identical outreach messages.

More importantly, the quality of those responses improved dramatically. Instead of skeptical replies asking for more information, I began receiving messages like:

"I saw your article in [Industry Publication] and was impressed by your approach to practice transitions. I've been considering my options and would be open to a conversation."

These warm responses led to more productive conversations and ultimately better acquisition opportunities. The investment in brand building paid dividends far beyond what I initially expected.

Creating Your Acquisition Identity

Building an effective acquisition brand starts with defining your acquisition identity—the core positioning that differentiates you from other buyers and resonates with your target sellers.

Defining Your Unique Acquisition Approach

Your acquisition approach is the foundation of your brand. It answers the fundamental question: "Why would a business owner choose to sell to you over other options?"

Consider these elements:

• Acquisition Philosophy: Are you a long-term holder or looking to grow and sell? Do you take a hands-on operational role or provide strategic oversight?

• Value-Add Proposition: What specific improvements can you bring to acquired businesses? This might include operational expertise, marketing capabilities, or access to capital for growth.

• Industry Focus: Are you specializing in specific industries where you have expertise, or taking a more generalist approach?

• Deal Structure Flexibility: How do you approach structuring deals? Are you open to earnouts, seller financing, or other creative arrangements?

• Post-Acquisition Treatment: How do you handle employees, customers, and the seller's legacy after acquisition?

Your answers to these questions form the core of your acquisition identity. This isn't just marketing, it should reflect your genuine approach and values. Authenticity is essential because sellers will quickly detect disconnects between your stated approach and actual behavior.

Crafting Your Acquisition Story

Once you've defined your approach, you need to craft a compelling narrative that communicates it effectively. Your acquisition story should explain your background, motivation, vision, values, and process.

Here's a simplified example:

"After 15 years building and selling my own healthcare services business, I realized my true passion was in growing existing businesses rather than starting from scratch. I now acquire well-established service companies with strong reputations but opportunities for operational improvement and growth. My approach focuses on preserving what makes each business special while bringing in systems and resources to help them reach their full potential."

This story quickly establishes credibility, motivation, focus, and values in a way that's both professional and personal.

Content Creation as a Deal-Finding Strategy

One of the most effective ways to build your acquisition brand is through strategic content creation. By sharing valuable insights related to your target industries and the acquisition process, you position yourself as a knowledgeable, credible buyer while attracting inbound interest from potential sellers.

Why Content Creates Credibility

Content creation builds credibility in several important ways:

• Demonstrates Expertise: Thoughtful content shows that you understand the industry, its challenges, and opportunities

• Proves Commitment: Regular content demonstrates that you're seriously committed to your acquisition strategy

• Shows Thought Leadership: Original insights position you as a forward-thinking buyer who can add value beyond capital

• Creates Familiarity: Consistent content helps potential sellers feel like they know you before you ever speak

• Builds Trust Over Time: A body of helpful content establishes trust gradually, which is often more effective than trying to build trust in a single conversation

The Content Types That Generate the Best Leads

Based on my experience, these content types produce the best results:

• Industry-Specific Articles: Pieces that address trends, challenges, or opportunities in your target industries

• Case Studies: Anonymized stories of successful acquisitions that illustrate your approach

• "Myth vs. Reality" Pieces: Content that addresses common misconceptions about selling a business

• Process Explanations: Step-by-step guides to aspects of the acquisition process

• Owner Transition Guides: Content focused on the personal and financial aspects of transitioning out of business ownership

The most effective content addresses questions and concerns that business owners have but may not be discussing openly. It should provide genuine value whether or not the reader ever sells to you.

Speaking and Media Opportunities

Content creation is powerful, but speaking engagements and media appearances can accelerate your brand-building efforts by putting you directly in front of potential sellers and their advisors.

Finding Speaking Opportunities

Speaking opportunities exist in virtually every industry:

• Industry Associations: National, regional, and local associations regularly need speakers

• Chamber of Commerce events and professional groups

• Educational institutions and virtual events

The key is to approach these opportunities with a value-first mindset. Focus on what you can teach that would benefit the audience, not on promoting your acquisition interests.

Leveraging Social Proof and Testimonials

Social proof evidence that others have had positive experiences working with you is one of the most powerful elements of a strong acquisition brand. It addresses the fundamental question in a seller's mind: "Can I trust this person with my business?"

Nothing builds credibility like the stories of sellers who have successfully sold their businesses to you. These testimonials and case studies demonstrate that you can deliver on your promises and create positive outcomes.

When collecting testimonials, always ask at the right time (after successful completion), offer anonymity options, provide clear usage parameters, and focus on specific elements rather than general praise.

The Compound Effect of Brand Building

Building your acquisition brand isn't a one-time effort, it's an ongoing process that compounds over time. Each article, speaking engagement, media mention, and testimonial builds upon previous work, creating an increasingly powerful presence in your target market.

Remember these key principles:

• Authenticity Matters: Your brand should reflect your genuine approach and values

• Consistency Builds Trust: Regular presence is more effective than sporadic efforts

• Value First, Acquisition Second: Focus on providing genuine value, and opportunities will follow

• Multiple Channels Reinforce Each Other: Content, speaking, media, and testimonials work together

• Patience Pays Off: The best results often take 6-12 months to materialize

Start with small, manageable steps perhaps a monthly LinkedIn article or a presentation at a local business group. As you build momentum, expand to additional channels and increase your frequency. The compound effect of these efforts will transform your acquisition results over time.

Your acquisition brand is your competitive advantage in a crowded marketplace. While others are cold-calling and sending generic outreach, you'll be building relationships, establishing trust, and creating opportunities that come to you.

That's the power of a well-developed personal brand.

Acquiring & Exiting is brought to you by the same team behind the: